‘Michelin star’ system a ‘shot in the foot’ for bars

24th January, 2017 by Annie Hayes

Introducing a Michelin star system for bars would be a “danger” to the industry as they risk making bars “homogenous and dull”, renowned bar owner Ryan Chetiyawardana has said at a P(our) panel discussion.

Alex Kratena speaking at the London panel discussion

Speaking at a P(our) collective event held yesterday [23 January] at The Town Hall Hotel in East London, Chetiyawardana expressed concerns that implementing an equivalent within the bar industry would be counterproductive.

“Frankly, what’s nice is that we have a range of bars and people are attracted to this industry from lots of different backgrounds because its not the boring same old thing,” said Chetiyawardana. “If we then develop a guide, are we then just not going to make a load of bars that none of us actually want to go and drink in?” He continued: “I worry that if we had a guide that was like Michelin we’d shoot ourselves in the foot.”

The discussion was part of a wider debate on whether too much emphasis is placed on awards, the involvement of spirits brands in competitions, and whether bars would benefit from the introduction of objective criteria – such as a Michelin Guide.

Joining Chetiyawardana on the panel was Zdenek Kastanek, general manager of Proof & Company, Singapore; Jake Burger, founder of Portobello Road Gin and The Ginstitute; Simon Ford, co-founder of 86 Company and chairman of The Spirited Awards; William Drew, group editor of World’s 50 Best Restaurants, World’s 50 Best Bars and Restaurant Magazine. The discussion was moderated by Jim Meehan, author of The PDT Cocktail Book and a member of the P(our) collective.

In contrast to Chetiyawardana’s views, Ford saw value in introducing a similar ratings system. “I talked about it a lot with Henry Besant back in the day,” he said. “It was something we really wanted to do ,and it was a gigantic monumental task to find different people in different places… Our industry is new [and] I think we were thinking too big when we [considered] it.

“Just like Michelin does, you could start with one city and [expand] one at a time. I would love to see it, and if I wasn’t trying to build a small business, I would love to do it. One day I hope to get to it if no one has done it first.”

“As the industry grows I think we’re getting to a place where that could happen and I think it would be great,” Meehan added.

Kastanek agreed, adding that bringing objectivity is a “number one” priority for the sector, which does not even have a ‘basic’ awards criteria to follow.

“It will bring lots of parity to everyone,” he explained. “Having a book like Michelin Guide works for consumers, so they can just look through and decide where they’re going to go for a drink when they’re travelling around the world.

Backing Chetiawardana, Drew argued that awards should be a “by-product” of running a great bar.

“The flip side of so-called transparency is that you have set criteria,” he said. “If you have set criteria, people chase that criteria. And if people chase that criteria, they’re effectively chasing awards – or in restaurant cases, a Michelin star. That’s not necessarily a healthy thing.”

Summing up, Mehan said: “Part of P(our) is to try and take these controversial subjects that tend to rub people the wrong way and stick our fingers in them – kinda get our hands dirty – and try to hopefully come up with not just problems, but to come up with solutions.

“One of the things I love the most about our industry – and one of the reasons why I think bartending is such an amazing job – is that bartending is all about problem solving. Every single interaction, moment in your life has the potential to be fraught with conflict, and your job as a bartender is to smooth that over.”

The P(our) concept was founded by Alex Kratena and Simone Caporale in April 2016 as a “bartender collective” that seeks to “build a holistic community for the global drinks industry”.

It held its first symposium in Paris in June 2016, which was attended by professionals from the drinks industry and beyond.

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to our newsletter

Subscribe today to get each issue of The Spirits Business as soon as it's published, plus all the latest breaking news and access to our library of back issues.

Subscribe Today!

Subscribe to our daily newsletter

Stay up-to-date with the latest news about the international spirits industry every weekday lunchtime (GMT)