Legal definition would ‘not benefit’ craft spirits

16th July, 2014 by Amy Hopkins

Despite controversy surrounding big spirits brands marketing their products as “craft”, the sector should not be bound by a legal definition, according to a leading US master distiller.

Lance-Winters

Lance Winters, master distiller of St George Spirits, believes the craft spirits sector would not benefit from an official definition

Speaking to The Spirits Business, Lance Winters, master distiller at California-based craft distillery St George Spirits said that despite the thought that larger companies are “masquerading as craft”, an official definition which could ban such companies from marketing themselves in this way, would not be beneficial to the sector.

“It doesn’t take long to look across the market and spot products masquerading as craft, but really the term is simply being used as a puppet by big organisations. This happens all too often – these products have craft packaging but they are not truly craft.

“However, though I think consumers should be armed with skepticism, I think putting an official legal definition on what crafts spirits would be too limiting for the industry.

“Putting a binding definition on what craft is, would be like putting a binding legal definition on what art is.”

Winters added that he instead believes that there should be an enforced “legal transparency” in spirits labelling, as companies “should not be able to get away with lies”.

Similarly, Chip Tate, head distiller at famed Bourbon craft distillery Balcones, said that although large companies “certainly appropriate the craft term”, a legal definition should not be implemented because “politicians are not necessarily tuned into what craft really is”.

“But we still need to have high level conversations about craft spirits,” he said. “We have to ask big companies what they mean when they say they are producing craft spirits. We have to hold them to account.”

Tate added that a legal definition of craft spirits that incorporates a size cap could also be problematic because this could deter companies from growth.

Currently, there is no government-enforced definition for craft spirits, yet the the American Distilling Institute (ADI) stipulates its own industry definition.

According to this definition, craft spirits are the products of an independently-owned distillery with maximum annual sales of 52,000 cases, where the product is physically distilled and bottled on site.

Executives at the ADI are currently applying to the US Patent and Trademark Office to have its definition of craft spirits officially recognised.

5 Responses to “Legal definition would ‘not benefit’ craft spirits”

  1. aphoticV says:

    I agree with them. It won’t really benefit small producers. I also don’t believe the big companies will want to talk about transparency – not in their interest.
    On the other hand, more and more people are associating the word “craft” with size. When it should be more about quality. Why not use “micro” instead, if trying to define by size.

  2. Chuck W says:

    Craft guys are the guys taking locally grown stuff and making spirits. Distilling, mashing , fermenting. Real craft guys have a local balance with their community. No shortcuts The liquor industry as a whole is loaded with so much smoke and mirrors its tough for the consumer to know where their drink really comes from. Craft makers ( true craft makers ) have nothing to hide.

  3. M says:

    With all due respect, the majority of people don’t care about whether something is craft and would rather buy their regular old Bailey’s or Beam. Craft distilleries should do themselves the favor of making obscure, unique or novel products that big guys can’t compete with, because they’re way too big to.

  4. N says:

    Important point of correction: The American Distilling Institute (ADI) is not a trade organization. It is a privately owned, for-profit business. There are two trade organizations representing distilleries in the United States: The Distilled Spirits Council and the American Craft Spirits Association. The American Craft Spirits Association is a registered non-profit trade organization run by a board of directors that was elected by member distilleries. It is not pursuing a legal definition of craft at this time, and will do so only if the membership indicates that it desires a legal definition. So far, they have not.

  5. Mike says:

    If the government decides to step in, or is invited to step in, the result will be bad for everyone from the distillers to the consumers.

Leave a Reply

If that's interesting, how about these?

Spirit Works Distillery appoints head distiller

California-based "grain-to-glass" distillery Spirit Works has promoted Lauren more...

Top 10 'top 10s' of 2016

Top tips for hangovers, the most unusual whisky cask finishes and family-owned more...

A drink with... Ian Harris, WSET

The CEO of the Wine & Spirit Education Trust tells The Spirits Business about more...

BrewDog slams 'deluded' council in distillery row

BrewDog has hit out at Aberdeenshire Council amid claims the authority is more...

California welcomes 'first urban distillery'

Distiller and blogger Laura Johnson is readying to open California's "first more...

Heaven Hill's Parker Beam dies

Heaven Hill master distiller emeritus Parker Beam has died at the age of 75 more...

Four Roses distilling head named KDA chairman

The Kentucky Distillers’ Association has named Ryan Ashley, chief operating more...

Buffalo Trace defends Old Charter label

Buffalo Trace Distillery is facing a proposed class action lawsuit in the New more...

Buffalo Trace teams up with America's Best Racing

Buffalo Trace Distillery has been named the 2017 official Bourbon of more...

'Oldest' Texas distillery wins trademark lawsuit

A Texas federal jury has ruled that the "first and oldest legal whiskey more...

Top 10 biggest spirits stories of 2016

The Spirits Business looks back at the biggest stories to rock the spirits more...

AB InBev and Keurig create home booze maker

Brewer Anheuser-Busch InBev and coffee maker Keurig Green Mountain have more...

Fair launches 'superfood' berry liqueur

'Socially responsible' spirits brand Fair has unveiled a new liqueur made using more...

Arnett: Many rye whiskeys ‘one-dimensional’

Jack Daniel’s master distiller Jeff Arnett has claimed many rye-based more...

Experts predict top spirits trends in 2017

If you're curious about what the coming year has in store for the global more...

Beam Suntory partners with Chicago Cubs

US baseball team Chicago Cubs has announced Beam Suntory as its official more...

D1 London gin and vodka to enter Chinese market

D1 London Spirits is set to launch its London Gin and Potato Vodka in China, in more...

The Kyoto Distillery in pictures

Join us for a tour around the unique, if diminutive, site that is pioneering more...

Jack Daniel's launches whiskey-infused coffee

Caffeine-crazed Jack Daniel's lovers can now have a taste of their favourite more...

Cannabis-based booze to be 'biggest disruptor ever'

In November 2016 a fresh wave of cannabis legalisation spread throughout the more...