Have strange botanicals taken gin too far?

8th July, 2014 by Becky Paskin - This article is over multiple pages: 1 2 3

Are gin producers risking distorting the perception customers have of the spirit by adding more and more extravagant botanicals? Becky Paskin investigates

Gin-botanicals

A tray of botanicals is loaded into a still to create Ferdinand’s Saar Dry Gin, but is the addition of German Riesling a step too far?

“The strangest botanical I’ve seen listed on a bottle of gin is the ‘half smiles of a cat’. I can’t for a second believe there is actual cat in there, but it’s an example of brands trying to be so different, they’re often pale.”

So says Desmond Payne, master distiller at Beefeater. Cat gin may be a step too far for him, but the lengths gin producers are going to to ensure their product stands out from the crowd is escalating. “The rise in the amount of different flavours available is because we’re in a gin craze right now,” explains Payne. “It’s an attractive route into what’s a pretty crowded market.”

At the last count there were some 150 gins on the market, with everything from traditional London dry styles, to gins made using unfiltered Icelandic water and exotic botanicals, such as coconut, eucalyptus, baobab, pomegranate and arbequina olives. German brand Saars even blends Riesling with its gin in a cross-category hybrid.

Spain’s extravagant gin and tonic culture is the first place to point the blame. “The Spanish consumer doesn’t generally go for cocktails but longer mixed drinks, so gin and tonics have become more sophisticated, creating demand,” explains Ellie Baker, creator and founder at Ish Gin and owner of Bristol Bar in Madrid. “It was a category that hadn’t previously been exploited.”

A subjective definition

While the gin boom in Spain exploded around three years ago, markets including the US, Western Europe and Australia are only now beginning to see an influx of new brand launches on home soil, each flaunting a unique flavour or style. These new additions to the gin market helped boost global volumes up 1.7% in 2012 to 62.3 million cases, according to Euromonitor, but while the longevity of these extravagantly flavoured gins is in doubt, their long-term effect on the market is still debatable.

According to EU and US legislation, gin, distilled gin and London dry gin must be “predominantly juniper tasting”, but if taste is the only means of measuring juniper content, it is completely subjective. “It is extremely difficult to measure a gin’s juniper level,” Payne explains. “The trouble is a lot of brands are secretive over their ingredients and I don’t think anybody’s disclosed the quantity of each, even if they do say what’s in it. You can measure oil content, but once it’s distilled, it’s quite hard to do.”

Without a definitive way to test a gin’s juniper content, and with so many feisty-flavoured botanicals now in use, how far is too far when it comes to adding untraditional flavours and botanicals to gin? For most, it’s simply a question of balance and moderation.

“There’s no limit to what distillers can choose to incorporate, but too far is when juniper is no longer the predominant flavour,” says Martin Dawson, co-founder of Broker’s Gin, while Payne adds: “As long as there’s juniper there, which makes it gin, the thing that really matters is the balance. If the flavours work together and they’re balanced, you can use any botanical, so long as it’s decent, honest and legal.”

5 Responses to “Have strange botanicals taken gin too far?”

  1. simon says:

    gotta say i don’t really give a shit about the opinion of beefeater, the world’s most boring and flavourless gin.

  2. Mike says:

    Showing your ignorance there Simon. Beefeater is FAR from “flavourless” and is a classic example of a London Dry Gin.

  3. BrianW says:

    “Predominately tastes of the juniper” a meaningless term. All spirits evolve wake up and move into the 21st century. Big boys are running scared f innovation. It is pathetic.

  4. I honestly don’t care if they use 2 or 200 botanicals as long as I get an aromatic, balanced and delicious spirit. Can’t they just add a special category for “other” gins?

Leave a Reply

If that's interesting, how about these?

Sazerac files another Fireball copycat suit

Sazerac has accused a Florida-based spirits company of planning to release a more...

Heaven Hill 'diligently' hunts for acquisitions

Following its takeover of Deep Eddy Vodka in 2015, US spirits firm Heaven Hill more...

Mattioni: Premium rums will ‘definitely develop’

The premium-plus rum segment in the UK will "definitely develop", driven by more...

SB Voices: Minimalist cocktail menus

Inspired by Tony Conigliaro's new Dalston-based bar, Annie Hayes touches on the more...

Scientists create 'brandy' in three days

Researchers in Spain have produced a grape spirit with the characteristics of more...

Fernet-Branca: A brand history

Fernet-Branca began life in an apothecary jar before becoming a long-time more...

UK gin smashes export record in 2016

British gin exports grew by 12% in 2016 to hit an all-time high, with sales more...

Russian Standard Vodka makes debut in Iceland

Russian Standard Vodka has entered the Icelandic market for the first time more...

Subscription service highlights experimental gins

As the at-home drinking trend continues to grow, two entrepreneurs have more...

Don Q releases spiced rum variant

Puerto Rican-rum brand Don Q has finally released its anticipated Oak Barrel more...

Scotland's Barra readies to release its 'first' spirit

A new independent spirits producer on the Scottish island of Barra is readying more...

SWA urges MEPs to back CETA deal

The Scotch Whisky Association has called on MEPs to back the EU-Canada more...

'World's first' coffee-infused mezcal launches

A UK entrepreneur has launched what is claimed to be the "world’s first" more...

Miller’s Norway distillery intros cask-aged akevitt

Marcin Miller’s Norwegian distillery Oslo Håndverksdestilleri has released more...

London's Mahiki launches coconut rum liqueur

London-based tiki nightclub Mahiki has unveiled a coconut rum liqueur and a more...

SB Voices: Experimentation in Irish whiskey

Nicola Carruthers reflects on the resurgence of the Irish whiskey category, more...

Pernod to roll out smart bottles 'in coming weeks'

Pernod Ricard will introduce 'connected' QR-coded bottles across its entire more...

New website lists NY distillery trails

An association of more than 60 distillers across New York has launched a new more...

Pernod Ricard eyes further acquisitions

Following Pernod Ricard’s re-entry into American whiskey with its Smooth more...

Industry hails EU-Canada CETA deal

Spirits Europe has “warmly welcomed” the European Parliament’s vote to more...