Jack Daniel’s defends Tennessee whiskey definition from Diageo

18th March, 2014 by Becky Paskin

Jack Daniel’s has warned that Tennessee whiskey is “under attack” by Diageo, as legislation proposed by the British drinks group allowing the reuse of barrels in production awaits approval.

Jeff Arnett Jack Daniels

Jeff Arnett, master distiller for Jack Daniel’s, argued that Diageo is working to “undermine” the Tennessee whiskey brand’s heritage

Jack Daniel’s owner Brown-Forman last year successfully led a campaign to have Tennessee whiskey recognised as a designation in the US.

Legislature was passed by the Tennessee General Assembly in May 2013 that protects Tennessee whiskey as being made from fermented mash of at least 51% corn, charcoal mellowed, and aged in new oak barrels within the State – the same recipe used for Jack Daniel’s.

However, Diageo, which owns the George Dickel Tennessee Whiskey brand, has since argued that allowing producers to reuse barrels more than once would deliver significant cost savings, not just for the British multinational, but craft producers too.

Its proposed change is currently pending approval at the Tennessee House State Government Committee and Senate State & Local Government Committee.

But Jeff Arnett, master distiller at Jack Daniel’s, views the proposal as less about freedom and more about “undermining the process we’ve worked for nearly 150 years to protect”.

“This is not about the interests of micro-distillers in our state,” he said. “We support micro-distillers. This is about Diageo, a large foreign company with more interest in Scotch and Bourbon, trying to weaken what Tennessee whiskey is and we simply shouldn’t allow it.”

Arnett argued the current designation protects Tennessee whiskey as a quality product: “No one is saying that companies can’t make the product however they want – whether that’s not charcoal mellowing it or even using old barrels. They just shouldn’t be able to label it Tennessee whiskey.

“It’s a real head scratcher why anyone would support legislation classifying our product as inferior to bourbon,” Arnett added.

Barrier to growth?

Diageo has responded with claims that Brown-Forman is attempting to “stifle competition” and a “new breed of distillers” by blocking the change.

“This isn’t about Diageo, as all of our Tennessee whiskey is made with new oak,” Guy L Smith IV, Diageo executive vice-president told Associated Press. “This is about Brown-Forman trying to stifle competition and the entrepreneurial spirit of micro distillers. We are not sure what they are afraid of, as we feel new innovative products from a new breed of distillers is healthy for the entire industry.”

Republican state representative Bill Sanderson agreed that the current requirement to mature Tennessee whiskey in new barrels is a challenge for small distillers. “We want to open it back up. We are still going to define Tennessee whiskey, but not as narrowly as Jack Daniel’s would like us to,” he told Fox Business.

As Jack Daniel’s manufactures its own American oak barrels, Sanderson argued the company already has a competitive advantage.

“They are a big bully picking on all the little guys,” he said.

Exports of Bourbon and Tennessee whiskey reached US$1 billion for the first time in 2013, with Tennessee whiskey one of the top 10 exports for the state.

3 Responses to “Jack Daniel’s defends Tennessee whiskey definition from Diageo”

  1. Cathy Marston says:

    This regulation has always surprised me from an environmental point – surely it is unsustainable and therefore ultimately undesirable to keep chopping down trees to manufacture new barrels?? As we become more aware of the evils of deforestation, perhaps it is time for a change in legislation to keep up with the times.

  2. Blue says:

    Even if the new law is reversed, JD will not stop using new barrels so it will not help the environment any! It would change the flavor profile from the past 100 plus years! The idea is that if burbon can set rules and have a specific formula, why can’t Tenessee Whiskey. Why isn’t Diageo fighting to lower the standards of bourbon so these small distilleries have an equal chance at producing bourbon as well? It’s not about the small guys to them! It’s about their competition and in the process ruining a tradition! The fact is, producing product of any kind for small craft distilleries is more expensive than it is for the large conglomerates! The cost of buying new barrels is reflected in their price and if the product is quality and good enough people will buy it. Then the more we buy the larger quantity of barrels they need in turn lowering their costs!
    Tennessee Whiskey should not be reduced to a lower standard for the sake of a Foreign Manufacturer. If it doesn’t follow the formula then it’s not Tennessee Whiskey! The Bourbon Standard is not being compromised, why should this!

  3. Tulkash says:

    Just a note about the used barrels. I agree it seems a bad environmental point to keep making new barrels. But they do sell the old barrels to other spirits distillers to be reused. Most rum and tequila is aged in old bourbon barrels as far as I know.
    Lots of Scotch’s and other whisk(e)y’s are aged in a few different types of barrels (sherry, port, etc.) to give different finishes.

Leave a Reply

If that's interesting, how about these?

Bardstown to 'reshape American whiskey market'

Bardstown Bourbon Company has started third-party production at its new US$25 more...

Whisky investment firm offers trading update

Whisky Invest Direct has seen its customers purchase enough liquid to make five more...

Benromach appoints fourth distiller

Single malt Scotch producer The Benromach Distillery Company has hired a fourth more...

Diageo's Special Releases 2016

Diageo has unveiled its much-anticipated annual collection of rare whiskies more...

W.L. Weller Bourbon proof and age 'will remain'

Buffalo Trace Distillery has unveiled new bottle designs for its W.L. Weller more...

Bushmills hails Ireland's first new cooper in 30 years

Bushmills Irish Whiskey apprentice Chris Kane has become the first person in more...

Diageo 'confident' of growth in fiscal 2017

Diageo’s 2017 fiscal year has “started well”, giving the group more...

Five honoured by Bourbon Hall of Fame

The Kentucky Distillers’ Association has recognised five Bourbon luminaries more...

2015's biggest spirits brands in travel retail

2015 was a mixed year for spirits in the global travel retail channel, with more...

Diageo North America streamlines commercial team

Diageo North America has announced changes to its commercial leadership more...

KDA welcomes Louisville Distilling Company

Louisville Distilling Company is the newest member of non-profit trade group more...

Ian Macleod buys Edinburgh Gin maker

Ian Macleod Distillers, maker of the Glengoyne, Tamdhu and Smokehead Scotch more...

Marks & Spencer lists Koskenkorva Vodka

Finnish drinks group Altia has struck up a deal with retail chain Marks & more...

The Whisky Exchange's top spirits trends for 2017

Insights released by London-based spirits retailer The Whisky Exchange suggest more...

Top 10 TR launches since TFWA WE 2015

As the 2016 TFWA World Exhibition & Conference approaches, SB recounts some of more...

Johnnie Walker Red Rye leads new series

Diageo-owned blended Scotch Johnnie Walker has launched the first expression in more...

Campaign launched to combat fake Irish whiskey

The Irish Whiskey Association and Ireland’s Minister for Agriculture have more...

Diageo ‘to cut jobs’ in productivity drive

The world’s largest spirits producer Diageo is reviewing staffing levels at more...

Luxco names US$35m site Lux Row Distillers

Work is progressing on Luxco’s new US$35 million Kentucky distillery, which more...

Whitley Neill releases Blood Orange Vodka

Halewood Wines & Spirits-owned Whitley Neill Gin has moved into vodka with the more...