Whisky age statements make industry “lazy”

11th September, 2012 by Becky Paskin

Age statements on whisky have made the industry “lazy and one-dimensional”, leaving a need for drinkers to be educated properly.

The Macallan 10 Year Old

The Macallan’s Gold in the new 1824 Series will replace its existing 10-17 Year Old whiskies

According to The Macallan, which will this month launch its ageless 1824 Series, the tendency for whisky producers to label their products with an age has misled consumers as to the quality of whisky in the bottle.

Speaking at the launch of The Macallan 1824 Series Gold, Joy Elliot, The Macallan brand ambassador, said the quality of a whisky should not be judged by its age, but rather by its character and flavour.

“Age statements have made us very lazy and one-dimensional,” she explained. “People have different palates and can each discern different flavours. What appeals to one person may not appeal to another. Right now whisky consumers believe an 18-year old is better than a 15-year old, and a 15 better than a 12, but it’s really all down to personal taste.

“Bob Dalgarno [whisky maker for The Macallan] wants to prove it’s not about age, but what’s in the glass and those whiskies that deliver character and flavour.”

The Macallan has prided itself over the years for refusing to add unnatural colouring to its whisky, preferring to allow its liquid to derive colour from the wood.

Joy added that as many consumers seemed to be unaware of the whisky-making process, the industry had a responsibility to educate buyers as to what true quality meant.

“There’s a big education job to do. We are the most modern market in terms of whisky, but we’ve still got a long way to go. An age statement doesn’t give you any clues as to quality, but this [The Macallan 1824 Series] is one of the ways around it.”

Despite claims last year that The Macallan 1824 Collection in global travel retail had not performed well due to its lack of age statement, Elliot claimed that since the change, sales of The Macallan had continued to grow, influencing other Scotch whisky producers to follow suit.

“This not only proves that consumers aren’t confused by the change, but that other companies think it’s a good idea too,” she said.

3 Responses to “Whisky age statements make industry “lazy””

  1. DavidUK says:

    Macallan are only coming out with this spin now because they are short of older whisky in casks. I will only believe they are sincere if they rebrand all their expressions with no age statement.

  2. paul says:

    Funny how “age statements have made us very lazy and one-dimensional” yet they are only using non age statements on their young whiskies. For some reason everything older than 18 will retain the NUMBER on the bottle. Hipocrites!!!! Its easier to sell an NAS bottle (with whisky <10yo) for a higher price than a bottle of 10yo, but luxury level prices REQUIRE age statements.

    If they had enough mid aged spirit (10-15 years) in their warehouses we wouldn't be hearing about age statements being one dimensional!

  3. […] dispute over aging statements in the scotch industry, when Macallan Brand Ambassador Joy Elliot said “Age statements have made [scotch-makers] very lazy and one-dimensional” at the launch of their 1824 Series Gold label. Elliot went on to explain how there are better ways […]

Leave a Reply

If that's interesting, how about these?

Laphroaig rolls out bottle label printing app

The latest initiative in Laphroaig's #OpinionsWelcome campaign is a bespoke more...

Scotch auction market hails ‘exceptional' 2016

Scotch whisky volume and value sales at auction reached record levels in 2016, more...

New website lists NY distillery trails

An association of more than 60 distillers across New York has launched a new more...

Scotch whisky trade groups partner up

Trade groups the Scotch Whisky Association and Scottish Craft Distillers more...

Barrie moves from Bowmore to BenRiach

Rachel Barrie, master blender at Beam Suntory division Morrison Bowmore more...

SMWS redesigns bottles for first time in a decade

The Scotch Malt Whisky Society has revamped its famous green bottle design for more...

Asahi Group’s spirits business slips 6.1%

Nikka owner Asahi Group saw its full-year whisky and spirits sales contract more...

Top 10 most collectible Scotch brands of 2016

Sellers are becoming "more confident" in placing high value bottles at auction, more...

The Macallan unveils Taiwan boutique exclusive

Edrington-owned single malt Scotch whisky the Macallan has unveiled the first more...

Wemyss releases 2017 single cask batch

Edinburgh-based independent bottler Wemyss Malts has released its latest batch more...

SWA urges MEPs to back CETA deal

The Scotch Whisky Association has called on MEPs to back the EU-Canada more...

Cîroc partners with Victoria’s Secret model

Diageo has recruited Victoria’s Secret model Alessandra Ambrósio for Cîroc more...

Subscription service highlights experimental gins

As the at-home drinking trend continues to grow, two entrepreneurs have more...

Premiumisation drives UK cocktail culture

The UK is fast becoming a nation of cocktail connoisseurs, with 77% of drinkers more...

John Walker & Sons Private Collection gets 2017 edition

Diageo has released the 2017 edition of its high-end John Walker & Sons Private more...

Scotch records 'best year' for exports since 2013

Scotch whisky exports have increased by both volume and value for the first more...

Bonhams hosts first online-only whisky auction

Bonhams is to launch its first online-only whisky auction in Hong Kong more...

R&B Distillers rolls out second While We Wait

R&B Distillers has released the second batch of its "lightly peated" single more...

Wild Turkey releases 35th anniversary bottling

Wild Turkey has launched Master's Keep Decades, a new Bourbon created in honour more...

Top 10 most investible Scotch brands of 2016

As Scotch whisky's value sales continue to soar, we round up the 10 more...